An article critique requires you to critically read a piece of research and identify and evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the article. How is a critique different from a summary? A summary of a research article requires you to share the key points of the article so your reader can get a clear picture of what the article is about Oct 01, · An article critique is a genre of academic writing that provides critical evaluation through intensive analysis of an article, which involves giving a brief summary of the blogger.comg an article critique helps an audience to understand the key points of the article, and the author’s ideas and intentions Article Critique Example. One of the ways of simplifying the whole process of completing the assignment is using an article critique example. Many students decide to download such samples in order to get an overall idea of how the assignment should look like and what key points should be added
How to critique qualitative research articles
Nurses use research to answer questions about their practice, solve problems, improve the quality of patient care, generate new research questions, and shape health policy. Nurses who confront questions about practice and policy need strong, high-quality, evidence-based research.
Research articles in peer-reviewed journals typically undergo a rigorous review process to ensure scholarly standards are met. Nonetheless, standards vary among reviewers and journals. This article presents a framework nurses can use to read and critique a research article. You may want to have a research article available to read and critique as you consider the following questions. A good title will pique your interest but typically you will not know until research article critique nursing are done reading the article if the title is an accurate description.
The abstract provides a brief overview of the purpose of the study, research questions, research article critique nursing, methods, results, and conclusions. Some people use the abstract to discuss a study and never read further. This is unwise because the abstract is just a preview of the article and may be misleading.
A good introduction provides the basis for the article. It includes a statement of the problem, a rationale for the study, and the research questions. When a hypothesis is being tested, it should be clearly stated and include the expected results. When a theoretical framework is used, research article critique nursing should inform the study and provide a rationale. The concepts of the theoretical framework should relate to the topic and serve as a basis for interpreting the results.
The literature review provides a context for the study. It establishes what is, and is not known about the research problem. Publication dates are important but there are caveats. Most literature reviews include articles published within the last 3 to 5 years.
It can take more than a year for an article to be reviewed, revised, accepted, and published, causing some references to seem outdated. Literature reviews may include older studies to demonstrate important changes in knowledge over time. In an area of study where little or no research has been conducted, there may be only a few relevant articles that are a decade or more old.
In an emerging area of study there may be no published research, in which case related research should be referenced. If you are familiar with the area of research, review the references to determine if well-known and highly regarded studies are included.
The methods section provides enough information to allow the study to be replicated. Components of this section indicate if the design is appropriate to answer the research research article critique nursing s. Independent and dependent variables should be described and terms defined. For example, if patient falls in the hospital are considered the dependent variable, or outcome, what are the independent variables, or factors, being investigated that may influence the rate at which patient falls occur?
The analytical approach relates to the study questions and research design. A quantitative study may use descriptive statistics to summarize the data and other tests, research article critique nursing, such as chi squares, t-tests, or regression analysis, to compare or evaluate the data. A qualitative research article critique nursing may use such approaches as coding, content analysis, or grounded theory analysis. Results should be clearly summarized in the text, tables, and figures.
Tables and figures are only a partial representation of the results and critical information may be research article critique nursing in the text. In a quantitative study, the significance of the statistical tests is important. The presentation of qualitative results should avoid interpretation, which is reserved for the discussion. It is essential that the limitations of the study be presented. These are the factors that explain why the results may need to be carefully interpreted, may only be generalized to certain situations, or may provide less robust results than anticipated.
Examples of limitations include a low response rate to a survey, not being able to establish causality when a cross-sectional study design was used, and having key stakeholders refuse to be interviewed. The discussion serves as an opportunity to explain the results in respect to the research questions and the theoretical framework.
Authors use the discussion to interpret the results and explain the meaning and significance of the study. Relevant policy recommendations are also important. Evaluate if the recommendations are supported by the data or seem to be more of an opinion.
A succinct conclusion typically completes the article. Determine the scientific merit of the study by evaluating the level and quality of the evidence.
Consider what you learned and decide if the study is relevant to your practice or answered your question as well as whether you can implement the findings. A systematic approach to reading and critiquing a research article serves as a foundation for translating evidence into practice and policy. Every nurse can acquire this skill. At the end of this article is a checklist for evaluating an article, research article critique nursing.
Leonard Corgan Library. Reading a research article. Accessed September 5, Oliver D, research article critique nursing, Mahon SM. Reading a research article part I: Types of variables. Clin J Oncol Nurs. Reading a research article part II: Parametric and nonparametric statistics. Reading a research article part III: The data collection instrument. Rumrill P, Fitzgerald S, Ware, M. Guidelines for evaluating research articles.
Discussion explains the results in relation to the theoretical framework, research questions, and significance to nursing. Decide if the study is applicable to your practice. This article will help me with my understanding of how to read and critique a research article. This article was helpful in breaking down this information very basic to get a clear, concise understanding. Now I can take this information and go to the next level in my discussions.
As I only have 2 more classes to get my degree, I wish I knew this info 2 semesters ago! I will also pass this along to coworkers that will be going back to school in the near future. well explained. its sometimes hard for P. G students to understand the concept but these guidelines are helpful to learn for novice.
This is great,am research article critique nursing for guilgline on how to do research critique and this is just the solution. Thnks weldone. I am currently taking a Health Service Research course and was not sure how to sturcture my assignment, research article critique nursing. Thanks for posting this article! Great timing; have just been asked to review and article and you provide the guide!
Will share with colleagues. I will be passing this article on to a friend who is taking a nursing research class, research article critique nursing. This article is a great reference for nursing students.
Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Powered by www. No part of this website or publication may be reproduced, stored, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the copyright holder.
Login About Contact Us Media Kit HealthCom Media. American Nurse American Nurse. Sign in. research article critique nursing username. your password. Forgot your password? Get help. Create an account. your email. Password recovery. Home Features Reading and critiquing a research article. Features Professional Development.
Reading and critiquing a research article. October 11, Author s :. Does the title accurately describe the article?
Is the abstract representative of the article? Does the introduction make the purpose of the article clear? Is a theoretical framework described? Is the literature review relevant to the study and comprehensive?
How To Critique A Research Paper, Article, Journal (Critical Appraisal)
, time: 24:32Reading and critiquing a research article - American Nurse
A new framework for critiquing health-related research is presented in this article. More commonly used existing frameworks tend to have been formulated within the quantitative research paradigm Future research on online orientation programs with a clear description of the program among a larger more diverse sample is necessary to provide evidence of the impact of online orientation programs. Summarize the key points of the article and your analysis. This closing sentence provides direction for future research RESEARCH QUESTIONS: Nursing question mean generating and assessing evidence for nursing (Hilarie, , p). In this article author did not clearly state the researcher question, the author did ask research question, and author further divided the each research question in to sub categories for more understanding of problems
No comments:
Post a Comment